Settlement Agreement / Alternate Dispute Resolutions

A. Settlement Agreement


Most disputes end in reconciliation or compromise, rather than a court decision. Disputes can be settled through simple negotiations or through the various forms of Alternate Dispute Resolutions (see below).


A settlement agreement is a legally binding agreement between two parties to settle a dispute. One party will usually pay the other party a settlement payment in return for the other party to waive any claims in the court. The parties are usually required to keep the terms of the contract confidential, such as the settlement amount and the circumstances surrounding the dispute. It is also common to include clauses that prohibit either party from making any derogatory comments on the other.


In addition to settling disputes under civil litigations, settlement agreements are also commonly used in the employment context to resolve employees' claims against employers. An employee or worker may agree to waive / not to make a claim against an employer in court or the labour tribunal in return for a severance payment.


The agreement to waive all actual and potential statutory (usually common law) claims should be set out in a written settlement agreement that will be tailored to specific employees and their personal circumstances. They must include a waiver of specific claims that the employee has or may have in the future. There are certain statutory requirements that a settlement agreement for employment must meet in order to be valid. Therefore care should be taken when drafting such agreement and consult your local employment lawyer if necessary.


B. Alternate Dispute Resolutions


Instead of going through the long, drawn-out and costly legal process. Parties may also consider the following Alternate Dispute Resolution method. Arbitration is the default for cross border agreements created on DocPro between parties from New York Convention countries.


1. Negotiation


Disputes in the first instance to be discussed between the chairmen or chief executives of the Parties in an attempt to resolve the dispute by negotiation. The advantage of including an express provision in the Agreement avoids the disputes becoming deadlocked at the lower level. A common negotiation clause allows seven days for such discussions, but the parties will always be free to extend this period in respect of any dispute.


2. Expert Determination


For more technical issues, the Agreement can provide for disputes to be referred to a panel of experts. This is usually a panel of three or five, each party nominating a Member (and an Alternative if five), and the parties agreeing on the appointment of the President. Alternate appointment can be made by the International Centre for Expertise of the International Chamber of Commerce (a different appointing body may well be more suitable depending on your location). Ideally, the Panel should be identified prior to the signature of the Agreement and the names included in an appendix to the contract. It is essential that the Panel is in place in the event a dispute arises.


3. Mediation


The parties are always free to agree to proceed to mediation at any time but the advantage of including an express provision is that it requires the parties to attempt such procedures before embarking on a full-blown arbitration / litigation at great cost and commitment of management time. The parties shall agree on a suitable procedure, and in default of agreement, such procedures are to be established by the mutual adviser appointed by agreement, or in default of agreement by a suitable appointing body. One may wish to specify the procedure in the Agreement or to incorporate standard procedures such as the conciliation procedure published by the ICE or the ICC.


4. Arbitration


The final tier of alternate dispute resolution is arbitration as opposed to litigation. The obvious advantage of arbitration is that it avoids recourse to the courts of any one jurisdiction which may have a less developed legal system but rather can provide a "neutral" venue and forum for the resolution of disputes between parties from different countries. Prior to deciding on the venue of arbitration, one should check whether an international convention (e.g. New York convention) is in place providing for the recognition and enforcement of international awards.


Settlement Agreement